August 9, 2022

Career Interests, Personal Passions and Labor Market Needs

The career interests shared by respondents in the First Career Steps survey reflect a wide range of interests, reflecting awareness of the needs of the local community blended with academic and personal interests. Most-common choices include some well-known career options such as teaching, engineering and medicine. Other common choices reflected personal interests in the arts, music, sports, fashion, animal care, and more, and in these, many answers reflect awareness of the challenge of many hard-to-break-into careers, listing several related alternatives: such as “fashion designer” plus several alternate paths; or “professional athlete” plus several alternate paths.

In open-ended questions, many respondents noted that they were still exploring options. Many respondents especially said that that they would like their schools to provide career information about a wide variety of career options in addition to the “big, well-known” jobs, expressing their desire to learn about less-well-known career paths.

As professionals providing career development education for youth, we often hope that youth will be interested in careers in newly emerging and growing industries and occupations, as well as in well-established career paths. We hope they can pursue careers that will meet community needs while providing personal satisfaction plus high pay, benefits, and career stability. We may worry when large numbers of students in our schools and communities express interest in the hard-to-break-in career pathways, with what feels like “too-many” aspiring singers, fashion designers, and professional athletes. We are concerned when what feels like “not-enough” students in our schools and communities are exploring computer programming, science, robotics, advanced manufacturing, and other STEM fields. While we know that student career interests will not precisely mirror labor market demand, we hope that students will take first career steps that will lead to a next-generation workforce that meets the needs of the local, regional and national economy and fulfills their personal and financial needs.

What do the First Career Steps survey results show? When asked “Do you know yet what career areas interest you?” about half responded “YES, I can name 2 or 3 career areas that interest me” and about 20% responded “YES, I have one strong career goal.”

In the next question, they were asked to list up to four career areas that might interest them, and most, even many of those who answered “NO” or “NOT YET” were able to list some career interests. The chart below lists the most common answers.

The “big, well-known” jobs were among the most-often-mentioned, in the top-ten, including teacher, nurse, engineer, doctor, and police officer. Some hard-to-break-into jobs were prominent in the top 20 or top 30 jobs, including athletes, artists, musicians, and fashion designers. Video game design was one of the top 20 most-often-mentioned fields; with many others saying that they wanted to own or work in a game store; and a significant number who just said they wanted to be gamers. The word “video” or “game” appeared in these responses 237 times (excluding fish & game wardens). “Youtube” appeared 39 times. In contrast, looking at some of the career fields that we consider important, emerging fields: the word “robot” or “robotics” appeared only 10 times, the word “environment” appeared only 34 times, and the words “climate,” “sustainable,” “ecology,” “energy” or “renewable” appear 5 times in total.

The first chart below shows the 30 most-common answers, and then the second chart provides a spotlight on a handful of unique answers, showing that while many answers clustered in a few common fields, there were many others, such as these, that reflected unique interests.

Most common answers – Top tenMost common answers 11-20Most common answers 21-30
Teaching
Nursing
Law/Lawyer
Psychology
Engineering
Veterinary / Vet Tech
Police/Law Enforcement
Doctor/Physician
Business/Business Management
Biology
Entrepreneurship
Chef/Culinary
Athlete
Theater/Acting
Writer
Photography
Architecture
Art/Artist
Video/Game Designer
Accounting
Fashion Design
Physical Therapy
Graphic Design
Musician
Interior Design
Forensics
Social Work
Cosmetology
Dentist/Dentistry
Pharmacist
Spotlight: Unique Career Interests
Animal-Assisted Therapy
Architectural – Structural Engineering Technician
Choral Director/Music Ministry
Commercial & Industrial Design
Ecologist-Sustainable Agriculturalist
Environmental Health Investigator
International Development Institutions
Labour Relations and Human Resources
Renewable Energy Technology
Water Treatment Facility
Work with a Charitable Foundation

These survey results are valuable as conversation openers. These results represent 7500+ student responses over ten years, primarily from the United States but also some responses from many other countries including Canada, UK, India and other countries. Some respondents found the survey while browsing online for career information, while others were assigned to take the survey as part of a career development class or workshop in their school. In both cases, these respondents tend to be at least somewhat engaged in career exploration, through their school or on their own. The set of responses would not include students who are not at all engaged in career exploration.

As career development professionals, what ideas and strategies can we glean from these results? What questions do these results raise?

  • What career interests do we “hope to see” among students in our schools and communities?
  • What career ideas would students be eager to learn about? What careers are important to our communities but less-often-explored by students? Respondents write that they would like their schools to help them learn about careers beyond the big, well-known jobs like doctor or lawyer. How can schools and communities make this happen?
  • How can career exploration balance the need to build a future workforce that meets local, regional and national needs, while also fulfilling the personal, financial and professional goals of individuals?
  • How can we guide students as they turn their initial career interests into first career steps and then to lifetime careers?

In conversation about the many students interested in the field of video game design, Mary Walek, a career development educator, said that postsecondary study with a focus on video game design (one of the top 20 most-common choices) can be a viable first career step, despite worries that it is popular beyond its actual share of the job market. She says that many students “don’t yet see the depth and complexity of this industry,” but once immersed in the field, they will find that the same skills in computer programming, graphic design, animation and storyboarding that are needed in video game design are valuable transferable skills that can lead to a wide range of jobs in the computer programming and graphic design fields and beyond. She added that the same is true in many industries, and that first career steps inspired by an initial area of interest will uncover many more opportunities, as students discover the depth and complexity of the industries they are exploring.

Survey respondents wrote about the importance of “knowing yourself” as part of career exploration, but also about a desire to learn more about less-well-known career paths.

  • I think that [my school] should do more seminars which focus on knowing our personalities so that we would be able to align our attitude with our future career path, since most of us, students are confused and are having a hard time with matching our personalities with our chosen careers.
  • [Students] should take a personal growth class to know who you are, what you know about yourself.
  • In my school we have a research rotation for 30 days, then after research we have a speech rotation for 30 days. In both of them rotations we do research about our future career and then we do a presentation on what we want to do in our futures. I would love my school to actually give us more time on what we would like us to do and guide us more by our personalities.

Some respondents wrote about the balance between understanding the labor market vs. following one’s passion:

* My school has career seminars where alumni come and talk about their careers.    [The school] should be more upfront about career data (path, salary, etc.) instead of going with the “follow your passion” mantra.
* The most helpful things my school is currently doing to help students learn about careers is having a project to research 5 careers that interest you, what their yearly salary is, and what colleges offer the best learning environment for that career.

Respondents who had career-themed classes, internships, and other hands-on opportunities stated that these were especially valuable. Other respondents said that they would like to see more internships and other hands-on opportunities in their schools.

  • The school I’m attending provides numerous resources and backgrounds on what types of jobs I’m interested in (plus dozens more). I’m looking into spending time reading over these resources and filing for plans to experience them. The school also provides multiple ways of shadow-working and hearing from someone experienced within a path.
  • One of the most helpful things in my school’s program is that they bring up conversations to each student about career options, they provide hands on experience to students who want to become engineers and music producers.
  • In the college and career academy I am taking a culinary class that will give me real experiences with cooking in a restaurant kitchen and working for someone else and also working with other people.

REFLECTION AND FURTHER EXPLORATION

In my work on the concept of the “Mosaic Economy,” I like to describe the economy as a mosaic, with many viable career paths. Similarly, I like to describe our personal career paths as “mosaic-economy career paths.” A successful career path evolves over time, shaped by both labor market opportunities and personal passions, and shaped by the way that “one thing often leads to another,” often leading to careers that most high school students have never heard of. In a Skills Library project called the “Career Directions” survey, about two-thirds of adult career professionals have said that they did not know when they were in high school that they would be in their current career. But many pointed to broad theme or interest that got them started, and to the skills and early career experiences that helped them along the way.


A next article about the First Career Steps survey will focus on survey questions about career skills, continuing the focus on how these survey results can open up conversations about career development education.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.